Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Having had a gynecological cancer, I asked several doctors and natural practitioners about the soy-hormone connection and whether I should avoid the stuff.
    The consensus seems to be that, if you’re drinking soy milk by the quart, eating edamame and tofu in large amounts at every meal, and using soy condiments and snack foods every single day, maybe cutting back would be a good idea. But the reasons to cut back would have more to do with single-sourcing protein intake and possible over-consumption of protein, more than the hormonal thing.
    Basically, you’d have to eat more than you’d want to in order for the hormone thing to affect you negatively. EXCEPT IF you’ve been diagnosed with hypothyroidism and/or are taking thyroid medication. If so, have that discussion with your own doctor because soy is believed to interfere with the absorption of the drug.

    Otherwise, avoiding chlorine makes much more sense (women in areas where water is treated with chlorine have been found to have higher cholesterol levels, and chlorine absorption inhibits thyroid hormone production) than worrying about eating soy every day of the week.
    We can do many other things in our daily lives to avoid hormonal imbalances (avoiding phthalates in cosmetics, as well as avoiding pesticides, BPA plastics, and other hormone disruptors) rather than cutting out a healthy source of protein for vegans!

  2. Interesting post – and definitely relevant for all vegans! You include some great options here.

    I personally do not miss cheese at all – even though I used to love it in huge quantities (I was a serious addict) – but I’m keeping these tips up my sleeve in case I come across anyone finding the transition difficult.

  3. I have a question about soy (specifically tofu) – I try not to eat it too often because I’ve heard it can mess around with your hormones. Is this true? Right now, I eat it about 2 times a week and I’ve switched to using almond milk instead of soy milk. I’ve been making my own cheese using cashews so I don’t eat too much soy. Am I being a little ocd? I’m trying to lose a substantial amount of weight and I’ve been doing the Eat to Live diet for 2 weeks now, but I’ve been gluten and dairy free for a year now, and an on again/off again vegetarian. This is the first time I’ve done a vegan diet, so I’m trying to make sure I keep up with my protein. I eat lots of beans, but soy seems to be a big shot of protein. Anyway, thanks for your website. I’m going to try out your zucchini ranch dip tomorrow. (sorry I’m rambling). Thanks in advance for your response.

    • Hi Heather

      I don’t personally worry about tofu. Perhaps if someone had a hormonal disorder they should look into it along with their doctor, but for most people that is not the case.

      Here’s some articles about soy: http://zenhabits.net/soy/ http://www.solae.com/Soy-Markets/Sports-Nutrition/Know-the-Truth-About-Increased-Soy-Intake.aspx

      Are you allergic to wheat or a diagnosed celiac? I find a lot of people are unnecessarily on a gluten free diet because of confusion in the natural health world. I’m going to do an article or something later on about this. Most gluten free food is unhealthy and highly processed and contains a lot of fat, so unless someone has celiac disease or a wheat allergy I don’t think you should be on a gluten free diet “just because”. Avoiding gluten and grains and eating other whole plant foods instead is fine, but avoiding gluten to eat processed packaged gluten free items isn’t.

      Hope that gives you some information.

Trackbacks

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *